Is this Israel lowest point?
The morning of October 7, 2023 was Israel's darkest moment as it literally was caught with its pants down as terrorists entered the country leisurely with the intent to kill as many people as possible, jews or not and start a new war against Israel The whole world was in shock and wondered how could this happen to a country with one of the most powerful armed forces and best intelligence services; similar to how we were in shock during 9/11.
There will be plenty of time to understand what went wrong and identify all the mistakes made over many years that allowed something of this magnitude to happen. Simply put, the Israeli Government and its leaders COMPLETLY failed in its most important duty which is to protect its citizens. After the holocaust, all Jewish people have lived with the mantra of NEVER AGAIN! and yet we were failed by those in power and with the responsibility for such atrocities to never happen again!
The two weeks after this terrorist massacre have become Israel lowest point in its 75 years history. Bluntly speaking Israel is lost and has no idea of what is the course of action anymore. Most rational governments tend to be prepared for worst case scenarios and simulate potential responses which they hope never have to carry out as for example the threats of nuclear war during the cold war. But clearly this government has been busy with other more important priorities than being prepared to protect its citizens, even thou we all know our neighbors stated objective is our destruction!
To me, it's very obvious that there's no strategy and not even a clear objective on how to respond. The conflicting messages coming from Netanyahu and those in power from we will annihilate Hamas to we will destroy Hamas military capabilities to carry such attacks again while they sound similar, they are actually world apart. The course of action for one or the other are very different and what each will entail.
Over 300,000 reservists were called up in order to act swiftly and with the intention to go into Gaza and eradicate Hamas. Two weeks later, Israel is still debating if to send ground troops or not? 200 hostages taken and very little effort to save them and liberate them? we all know that the more time that passes in any hostage situation the more difficult any rescue mission becomes. Was Israel so taken by surprises that they simply have no idea where the hostages are?
The Israeli response so far has been to play into Hamas game. Hamas wants Israel to come into Gaza as they know the playbook by now and how this changes the narrative to make Israel the aggressor and rally the international community against Israel atrocities. Israel not only has the right to defend its people but also a duty to do so. But any action should stem towards solving the terrorism problem as well as with a view of peace in the future and not simply out of a desire for revenge. No matter what different factions think and all the historic blame the fact of the matter is that Arabs and Jews are neighbors and unless one side is prepared to commit genocide we need to find a way to bring peace.
The dichotomy Israel faces between defending itself and dealing with terrorism and impeding future danger has brought up (once again) very difficult moral and existential question to Israel which sadly I think are not being addressed out of a desire for revenge. Can Israel justify any action and any indiscriminate palestinian loss of life just because terrorism was committed against them? Has Israel become a state with no morals and in which the end justify the means and where killing one hamas terrorist is ok even if it means 1,000 other lives of Palestinians, innocent or not?
Can Israel stick to its moral high ground and make excuses such as Hamas uses people as human shields or hides itself in mosques and schools or simply tell palestinians to flee where it will bomb and pretend that is enough? I don't think so! Doing so makes Israel dangerously act almost as terrorists, albeit very different intent and circumstances. Israel knows how Hamas operates and therefore if it values human lives then needs to find a way around this and not simply blame Hamas for using human shields. Similarly, telling people to leave their homes because they are about to be bombed is not enough. Palestinians in Gaza aren't free and they cannot simply leave. Many get killed by Hamas if they try to flee and Israel knows this. So for Israel to pretend it does everything it can to minimize human casualties it's very debatable.
The next couple weeks will probably define the Israeli-palestinian conflict and the middle east for years to come. Israel is at its lowest point in history, led by the wrong people, with the wrong intentions and clueless about the right course of action. There are dark times ahead and sadly peace in the region is further and further away. I can only hope for both Palestinians and Israelis to work towards our common goal which is to preserve human life and get rid of terrorism which is the real common enemy of both!

